Learn More
Italy, a country deeply rooted in Roman Catholic traditions, presents a complex legal landscape for LGBTQ+ individuals seeking recognition and rights for their families. Despite some progress, Italy remains behind many other European nations in terms of legal recognition and protection for same-sex couples, particularly regarding marriage, adoption, and surrogacy. For Americans in same-sex marriages who are considering pursuing Italian citizenship, it is crucial to understand the restrictions and limitations imposed by Italian law before taking any steps toward becoming an Italian citizen.
Civil Unions vs. Marriage
As of June 2023, same-sex couples in Italy can enter into civil unions, thanks to the Cirinnà law passed in May 2016. These unions provide most of the legal rights associated with marriage, such as inheritance rights and the ability to make medical decisions for a partner. However, they fall short in key areas, notably in the absence of joint adoption rights. The law does recognize same-sex couples as a family unit, and the Supreme Court of Cassation has allowed for the adoption of stepchildren within these unions. Yet, these legal frameworks stop short of granting full parental rights to non-biological parents.
Adoption Rights: A Complicated Path
Adoption in Italy is a lengthy and complicated process, particularly for same-sex couples. The lack of joint adoption rights means that when a legal parent in a same-sex couple dies or becomes incapacitated, the surviving partner has no automatic legal rights over the children. This situation could lead to the children becoming wards of the state or being placed with other relatives. Some advocates have urged Italian mayors to register both same-sex parents on birth certificates as an act of civil disobedience, but the legal framework remains resistant. A recent ruling by a top court has further complicated matters, stating that non-biological parents cannot automatically be listed on children’s birth records. This ruling reversed the practice of some mayors who had been certifying birth records from abroad that included non-biological parents.
In June 2024, the prosecutors' office in Padua ordered the removal of non-biological parents from the birth certificates of 33 children registered since 2017. This decision means that these children can no longer legally use the surname of their non-biological parent, a significant blow to the recognition of same-sex families.
Surrogacy: A Legal Minefield
Surrogacy has been illegal in Italy for two decades, and the country’s stance on the issue remains rigid. Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, a staunch Catholic, has been pushing for even stricter prohibitions. She has referred to surrogacy as “inhuman” and “uterus renting,” aligning her views with those of the Vatican. In 2023, the Italian parliament approved a bill that criminalizes Italians who engage in surrogacy abroad, imposing severe penalties, including prison terms of up to three years and fines of up to 1 million euros. This law specifically targets Italians who seek surrogacy services outside the country, further limiting the options available to same-sex couples.
Important Considerations for Americans
For any American in a same-sex marriage with children, it is imperative to learn about these restrictions before pursuing Italian citizenship. Unlike in the United States, where same-sex marriages are fully recognized and provide comprehensive parental rights, Italy's legal framework is more restrictive. Civil unions in Italy do not offer the same level of recognition or protection, particularly when it comes to joint adoption and parental rights.
Understanding these limitations before taking steps to become an Italian citizen is vital. Being fully informed about Italy's legal stance on same-sex marriage, adoption, and surrogacy will help you make an educated decision and prepare for the potential challenges that may arise as you navigate the process of obtaining Italian citizenship.
The Road Ahead
The actions taken by the Italian government against same-sex couples are seen by many as a manifestation of the right-wing majority's hostility toward the LGBTQ+ community. These measures have sparked significant debate within the country and beyond, with some advocating for civil disobedience and others calling for comprehensive legal reforms.
Italy’s current legal framework fails to fully recognize and protect same-sex families, leaving many couples in a precarious legal position. The fight for equal rights continues, with LGBTQ+ advocates pushing for the same recognition and rights that are afforded to heterosexual couples. As Italy grapples with these issues, the question remains: will the country move towards greater inclusivity, or will it continue to uphold laws that many see as discriminatory and outdated?
4o
Story tags:
